Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland
The Representativeness of Participants With Severe Mental Illness.pdf (189.23 kB)

The Representativeness of Participants With Severe Mental Illness in a Psychosocial Clinical Trial.

Download (189.23 kB)
Version 2 2021-12-21, 12:12
Version 1 2019-11-22, 17:11
journal contribution
posted on 2021-12-21, 12:12 authored by John LallyJohn Lally, Rochelle Watkins, Sarah Nash, Hitesh Shetty, Poonam Gardner-Sood, Shubulade Smith, Robin M. Murray, Fiona Gaughran

Introduction: Cardiovascular morbidity and mortality are increased in severe mental illnesses (SMI). Trials of psychosocial health interventions to improve physical health in SMI, including in treatment-resistant schizophrenia, have shown some benefit. However, the representativeness of participants in such trials has not been determined. Method: We utilized an anonymised case register to determine if participants in a randomized controlled trial (RCT) of a novel psychosocial health intervention aiming to improve physical health in SMI had similar severity of illness to eligible non-participants. A retrospective database analysis was performed, using Health of the Nation Outcome Scale (HoNOS) data from the sample of patients participating in the IMPaCT (Improving Physical health and reducing substance use in Psychosis) RCT (n = 293) compared to all eligible participants with a psychotic illness (n = 774). Results: The mean total HoNOS score in the eligible comparator population (Mean = 9.09, SD = 5.8, range = 0-30) was significantly greater than that of the IMPaCT RCT participants (Mean = 7.16, SD = 4.7, range = 0-26), (t = 3.810, p = 0.006), as was the degree of overall illness severity and functional impairment, as measured by HoNOS. Conclusion: This study shows for the first time that the patient population participating in an RCT of a lifestyle intervention for those with SMI had a better mental health status at entry to the trial, than the total eligible population, although there was no difference in physical health needs. This has relevance to the applicability of RCTs of lifestyle interventions in service planning and suggests that when people are more unwell, greater effort may be needed to include them in psychosocial interventions. A more careful and focused recruitment approach should be followed to improve the participation of the more severely ill patients in psychosocial interventions in order to enhance the external validity of such studies.


National Institute for Health Research (NIHR) under its IMPACTprogram (Grant Reference Number RP-PG-0606-1049)



The original article is available at

Published Citation

Lally J, Watkins R, Nash S, Shetty H, Gardner-Sood P, Smith S, Murray RM, Gaughran F. The Representativeness of Participants With Severe Mental Illness in a Psychosocial Clinical Trial. Frontiers in Psychiatry. 2018;9:654.

Publication Date


PubMed ID



  • Beaumont Hospital
  • Psychiatry

Usage metrics

    Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland


    Ref. manager