posted on 2022-07-22, 14:58authored byKathryn Yates
<p><b>Background:</b> Psychotic
experiences (PE) are common in the general population, and hallucinations are
most commonly reported. Research over
the past ten years has, in particular, highlighted a relationship between PE
and suicidal behaviour. </p>
<p><b>Aims</b>: The overall aim of this
thesis was to investigate hallucinations as a risk marker for suicidal behaviour in (1) the general
population, including looking at variation with regard to age, and (2) in
specific groups already known to have elevated risk of suicidal behaviour,
including (2a) individuals with a chronic neurological disorder (seizure
disorders) and (2b) individuals with specific psychosocial adversity (victims
of sexual assault). A further aim was to explore developmental sensitivity in
the relationship between psychosocial adversity (sexual victimization) and
psychotic experiences. In order to look at the overall general population, a
quantitative synthesis of the literature was conducted examining the
longitudinal relationship between psychotic experiences and subsequent suicidal
ideation, attempts and deaths in the general population (Study 1). Second, the
prevalence and clinical significance of hallucinations across the adult
lifespan was assessed (Study 2). Third, it was examined whether hallucinations
are a risk marker for psychopathology, suicidal ideation and suicide attempt in
individuals with a seizure history (Study 3). Then, the prevalence of
hallucinations, delusional beliefs and psychotic disorder in the context of
sexual assault was investigated (Study 4). Finally, it was examined whether
hallucinations were a risk marker for suicidal behaviour specifically in the
context of sexual assault (Study 5). </p>
<p><b>Method</b>: A systematic review and meta-analysis was
conducted for study 1. Analyses for the remaining studies were conducted using
the Adult Psychiatric Morbidity Surveys (APMS). The APMS studies are cross-sectional, national household surveys
representative of the general UK population. They have been conducted every
seven years since 1993 (2000, 2007, 2014) and represent the largest
epidemiological survey worldwide that uses consistent methods to assess the
prevalence of treated and untreated mental health conditions. The consistent
methods allow different study waves to be combined to allow robust testing of
hypotheses using large samples. </p>
<p><b>Results</b>: PE were associated with increased risk for
subsequent suicidal ideation, suicide attempt and suicide death in the general
population (Study 1). The prevalence of hallucinations decreased significantly
across the adult lifespan from age 16-95 years. Whilst hallucinations were
associated with increased risk for psychopathology and suicidal behaviour in
all age groups when compared to individuals without hallucinations,
hallucinations in older adults were less likely to be associated with a
co-occurring mental disorder, suicidal ideation or suicide attempt compared to
early adulthood and middle age (Study 2). There was an increased prevalence of
hallucinations in individuals with a seizure history. Hallucinations were a
risk marker for psychopathology, suicidal ideation, and suicide attempt in individuals
with a seizure history, with 65% meeting
criteria for one or more mental health disorder and 53% disclosing at least one
suicide attempt (Study 3). Individuals with a history of sexual assault also
had a higher prevalence of hallucinations, delusional beliefs and psychotic
disorder compared to individuals without a sexual assault history (Study 4) and
hallucinations were a strong risk marker for suicidal behaviour in the context
of sexual assault (Study 5). The relationship between hallucinations and
suicidal ideation and behaviour in all studies was not explained by other,
non-psychotic measures of psychopathology. <b></b></p>
<p><b>Conclusion:</b> Hallucinations
are common in the general population and occur at an elevated prevalence in
groups known to be at high-risk for suicide. What is more, even within groups
at already elevated risk, hallucinations are strong markers of increased risk
for suicidal behaviour. There
is age-related variation in the clinical significance of hallucinations in that
they are less likely to be associated with mental ill health, suicidal ideation
and suicide attempt in older age compared to hallucinations in younger and
middle-age. Hallucinations are a valuable risk marker for identifying
individuals with a particularly increased odds of suicidal ideation and
behaviour in high-risk groups. </p>
History
Research Area
Neurological and Psychiatric Disorders
First Supervisor
Prof. Ian Kelleher
Second Supervisor
Prof. Fiona McNicholas
Third Supervisor
Prof. Mary Cannon
Comments
Submitted for the Award of Doctor of Philosophy to the Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland, 2022
Published Citation
Yates K,. An Epidemiological Investigation of the Relationship Between Hallucinations and Suicidal Behaviour Across the Adult Lifespan and in High-Risk Groups. [PhD Thesis] Dublin: Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland; 2022